ÿWPC; ,FEÉow×9pÚKË=I¬OHú£,Ï#‚Gq‡„q_t4ÏùŸ†ø”¨xûŒgå’*q <™*ùgªìY¹¡¡³DD‹²D.½NCmÕÔqòaE's+™ˆ±šK?º=y“2ÜÀ™”ì^Ã"?]A¯Š”8¿È§™¼)ñ)g©\geH°M4šä±GUòÐb-òxæ},H 8û¢øxRsÊŸéMrÚØwued¶ôkâ¥î.Žðü$Ì^˜ªÕíà|óI ,õQ¡ÿdœ\iÏ1(j>Xß ç§zD!´Ë#k…Dð0^'~a±Ó`àM.n…ΩuµC×”yŒ~º/4Ö™Å4"îóûtŸM“áÖî¯$#Å¡&~±l× Mö À‰ÙÅgY¬®*G%#ð9Càm§`ã€ÏÂDŒ e%p¸Gžø’à_+ãr£‹ONËOÒÒšf2xNñ‚P¡'Aœ&ßæEk©þÝE÷8›åæ²WÔþÄzÑÃs)#¥Õ,¾‹Œw¡Jbóì™ö—÷È»NÐEƒsc1³† ’ƒ{å±–¸ žåû¨jàY”%b§ÖGõZ¯z3 „£ü¸˜Ã“ÒØCØYöƒ„V±PX ß€þý #†šUF  %f 0(l”UN£¦ñ4—J«UFõHP LaserJet IIIHP3.PRS,\,,\,ð×^Ñ^Ñ÷§@b×3^àhåþ 9Z#‹.Courier New RegularX($¡¡3|xJð@øÐ Z‹6Times New Roman RegularMinutes of February Meeting X3L8 Ë / ' (Bruce Bargmeyer(0Bruce Bargmeyer .   H:A¡¡ÿITIÿ ÿIRÿ ÿRosenÿÿLaPlantÿ<åþ 9Z ‹.Courier New RegularÝ ƒ!ÝÝ  ÝÓ  ÓÔ€X,XXXÔò òÔ‡„ౄXX,ÔÑ7€=…XdÔXXdì7ÑMinutesÐ ° ÐNinety„first€Meeting€of€X3L8€„€Data€RepresentationÌó óÔ#†X,X„„à±I#ÔÌÓÓÌDate:€February€23,€1995ÌÌPlace:€Information€Technology€Industry€(ITI)€Council€€Ì1250€Eye€StreetÌWashington,€D.C.ÌÌò ò1.0€Administrative€Mattersó óÐ Ð  ÐÌThe€meeting€was€convened€at€9:30€a.m.ÌÌ1.1€Minutes€of€Previous€MeetingÌÌThe€minutes€were€approved€as€drafted.ÌÌ1.2€Approval€of€the€AgendaÌÌThe€agenda€was€approved€after€adding€several€items.ÌÌ1.3€MembershipÌÌThe€attendance€list€and€address€list€were€circulated.€A€copy€of€the€attendance€list€is€provided€asÏAttachment€1€of€these€minutes.ÌÌ1.4€OfficersÌÌBruce€Bargmeyer€was€approved€for€Vice€Chair€X3L8.ÌÌ1.5€Document€DistributionÌÌThe€following€documents€were€distributed€at€this€meeting€or€by€prior€mailing:ÌÌà0  àà ° à1.5.1€IR€Transmittal€Sheet€for€U.S.€Comments€on€Comments€re€2nd€CD€11179„5€BallotÏ(Naming)Ð (#(# ÐÌà0  àà ° à1.5.2€IR€Transmittal€Sheet€for€U.S.€Delegates€to€SC€14/WG€4€and€SC€14€Plenary€meetingsÏ1994/10/11„17€and€1994/10/19„21€respectivelyÐ (#(# ÐÌà0  àà ° à1.5.3€IR€Transmittal€Sheet€for€U.S.€Member€Body€of€SC€14,€Proposal€for€Nomination€ofÏCandidate€to€Chairmanship€of€SC€14ÐP, '*(#(# ÐÔ  ÔÌà0  àà ° à1.5.4€SIS€Dispatch,€dated€1994„09„08€(X3L8/94„048)Ð (#(# ÐÌà0  àà ° à1.5.5€I€SIS€Dispatch,€dated€1994„09„27€(X3L8/94„049)Ð (#(# ÐÌ1.5.6€SIS€Dispatch,€dated€1994„11„02€(X3L8/94„050)ÌÌ1.5.7€Other€Documents€Distributed€in€Stockholm€(October,€1994)ÌÌ1.5.7.1€SC€14€Documents€(X3L8/94„051)ÌÌ1.2.7.2€SC€14/WG€4€Documents€(X3L8/94„052)ÌÌ1.5.7.3€SC€14/WG€4€Plenary€Documents€(X3L8/94„053)ÌÌ!.5.8€SC€ISO/IEC€DIS€11179„5,€Vote/Comments€due€to€WG€&€Convener,€NLT€3€Apr.€95.ÌÌò ò2.0€ReportsÐ \¬ Ðó óÌ2.1€Report€on€ISO/IEC€SC€14/WG€4€Meeting€in€Stockholm€October,€1994ÌÌBill€Kenworthey,€WG€4€Convener,€briefly€reported€on€the€progress€achieved€at€the€meeting.€ThisÏis€documented€in€the€report€of€the€meeting,€previously€circulated.ÌÌ2.2€Report€on€ISO/IEC€SC€14€Plenary€Meeting€in€Stockholm€October,€1994ÌÌThe€Chair€briefly€reported€on€the€meeting.€This€is€documented€in€the€report€of€the€meeting,Ïpreviously€circulated.ÌÌ2.1€Report€on€X3L8€SIG€meetings€held€at€NIST€ÌÌPhong€Ngo€briefly€described€the€progress€taking€place€at€the€meetings.€He€described€work€onÏvarious€parts€of€ISO/IEC€11179.€Work€on€Part€6€has€required€considerable€revision€based€onÏfurther€examination€of€the€workability€of€€Annex€H.€Paul€Hawes€discussed€the€issue€of€how€toÏdeal€with€terminology€between€Part€1€and€the€other€parts.€The€work€is€very€active,€monthlyÏmeetings€are€being€held€at€NIST€and€considerable€progress€is€being€made,€especially€on€the€X3L8ÏMetamodel€for€Data€Representation.€The€progress€is€further€described€in€the€meeting€reports,Ïwhich€are€up€on€the€NIST€anonymous€FTP€server.ÌÌ2.3€Report€on€status€of€terminologyÌÌPaul€Hawes€reported€on€the€effort€he€is€leading€to€document€and€integrate€the€terminology€used€inÏthe€various€parts€of€ISO/IEC€11179.€Paul€has€done€considerable€work€on€the€preparation€ofÏuseful€definitions.€Several€decisions€must€be€made€before€the€next€WG4€meeting,€because€they€areÐ T,¤'+ Ðneeded€to€complete€resolution€of€U.S.€comments€on€Part€5.Ð ° ÐÌ2.5€Liaison€Report€on€the€Project(s)€of€former€Task€Group€X3L8.4„Geographic€UnitsÌÌRoger€Paine€described€work€on€identification€of€water€bodies€of€€the€world.€The€ExecutiveÏSecretary€of€the€Foreign€Names€Committee€gave€a€draft€document€to€the€Foreign€Names€staff€atÏDefense€Mapping€Agency.€The€staff€reported€that€they€do€not€support€creating€a€standard€fromÏthe€work€of€€the€International€Hydrographic€Organization.€Although€this€work€is€well€acceptedÏaround€the€world,€the€staff€preliminary€statement€says€that€it€does€not€meet€the€requirements€of€aÏstandard.€Bruce€Rosen€raised€the€similarity€of€this€issue€to€ISO€3166€&€FIPS€1„5.€Names€are€aÏproblem.€The€current€naming€standard€in€ISO€11179€Part€5,€if€applied€to€data€element€values,€mayÏhelp€to€solve€the€problem.€Roger€will€work€further€on€the€issues€and€report€next€meeting.€ÌÌ2.6€Report€on€T1M1€activitiesÌÌNo€ReportÌÌ2.6€Liaison€Report€on€X3H4€activitiesÌÌX3H4€has€been€approved€as€TAG€for€the€SC€22€PCTE€activity€and€released€from€TAGÏresponsibilities€for€SC€21/WG€3€IRDS.€H4€membership€may€shift€to€PCTE€representatives.€TheÏwork€on€long„term€Repository€Technology€is€continuing.ÌÌ2.7€Liaison€Report€on€NISO€activitiesÌÌThe€next€international€meeting€of€TC€42€will€occur€in€Washington,€date€to€be€announced.€ÌÔ  ÔÌò ò3.0€Status€of€Projectsó óÐ ”ä ÐÌà0  àà ° à3.1€Status€of€Data€Element€Classification€and€Attribution€Project€(X3€Project€399„DT€and€400„¼DT)Ð (#(# ÐÌThe€classification€work€has€been€subsumed€by€the€11179€effort.€ÌÌ3.2€Status€of€Mnemonic€Codes€Algorithm€(X3€Project€455„D)ÌÌNo€progress.ÌÌ3.3€Status€of€ISO€11179€(Parts€1„6)ÌÌThe€status€of€these€projects€are€documented€in€the€annual€report€and€in€the€SIG€meeting€minutes.ÏConsiderable€progress€is€being€made.ÌÌ3.4€Status€of€the€SD3€for€X3L8€Metamodel€for€Data€RepresentationÐ T,¤'+ ЇBill€LaPlant,€the€OMC€representative€to€X3L8€made€some€suggestions€for€changes,€which€wereÐ ° Ðmade.ÌÌBruce€Bargmeyer€moved€and€Phong€Ngo€seconded€that€we€approve€the€SD3€for€development€ofÏthe€X3L8€metamodel€for€data€representation.ÌÌPassed:€7„0„12„0€(yes„no„total€members„no€response)ÌÌThe€Chair€agreed€to€draft€a€new€cover€letter€for€the€SD3.€Bruce€Bargmeyer€will€mail€a€copy€ofÏthe€revised€SD3€to€Bill€Kenworthey.ÌÌ3.5€Status€of€the€MOU€between€X3L8€and€CDIFÌÌThe€SIG€recommended€that€the€MOU€be€accepted€by€the€Plenary.€CDIF€members€have€reviewedÏthe€document€and€their€comments€have€been€approved.ÌÌPhong€Ngo€moved€and€Paul€Hawes€seconded€that€the€MOU€be€accepted€by€the€group,€signed€byÏthe€Chair,€and€delivered€to€CDIF.ÌÌPassed:€7„0„12„0ÌÌ3.6€Vote€and€comments€for€ISO€ballot€on€ISO/IEC€11179€Part€5ÌÌThe€SIG€prepared€comments€on€Part€5€and€recommended€the€comments€for€approval€at€theÏPlenary.€Paul€Hawes€moved€and€Judy€Newton€seconded€that€we€accept€the€recommendation€ofÏthe€SIG:€Vote€yes€on€the€ballot€and€attach€the€comments€prepared€by€the€SIG.ÌÌPassed:€7„0„12„0ÌÌ3.7€€Status€of€five„year€review€of€X3.38,€X3.31,€and€X3.47€(X3L8€Ballots)ÌÌThe€following€standards€were€reaffirmed€and€approved€by€ANSI€on€May€23,€94:€X3.38,€X3.31Ïand€ñJñXñJñ3.47.€Bill€Kenworthey€found€the€document€that€X3€sent€out€stating€this€per€request€fromÏX3.ÌÌò ò4.0€IR€Responses€to€SIS€through€CBEMA€and€ANSIó óÐ ô$D # ÐÌ4.1€Phong€Ngo€discussed€the€issues€related€to€Chairmanship€of€SC€14.€We€have€not€seenÏdocumentation€of€the€final€outcome.ÌÌThe€remaining€items€were€previously€discussed€in€1.5.1,€1.5.2,€and€1.5.3.ÌÌò ò5.0€New€Businessó óÐ h+¸&* ÐÐ T,¤'+ Ð6.1€Review€X3/SD„4€to€determine€standards€due€a€five€year€review€in€1995€ÌÌThe€Chair€discussed€the€issues.ÌÌ6.2€Report€on€upcoming€SC14/WG4€meeting€in€BrazilÌÌThe€meeting€announcement€was€distributed.€The€next€WG4€meeting€will€be€held€in€Brazil€on€MayÏ15„19,€1995.ÌÌ6.3€Response€to€French€Request€for€comment€on€proposed€New€Work€Item€on€Codes.ÌÌThe€document€that€we€received€did€not€illuminate€the€issue€further€than€what€was€discussed€at€theÏStockholm€SC€14€meeting.ÌÌA€response€was€drafted€by€Phong€Ngo€stating€that€we€need€the€white€paper€that€was€promised€atÏthe€Stockholm€meeting€in€order€to€determine€the€need€for€this€work.€Minor€revisions€wereÏsuggested€for€Phong's€draft.€Bruce€Bargmeyer€€moved€that€we€accept€the€response€as€revised.ÏPhong€Ngo€is€to€send€it€via€email.€He€will€provide€it€also€to€the€IR,€should€an€official€response€beÏrequired.€Seconded€by€Judy€Newton.ÌÌPassed:€€7„0„12„0ÌÌ6.4€Liaison€with€US€TAG€to€SC7ÌÌThe€chair€was€authorized€to€appoint€one€or€more€liaison€persons€to€the€US€TAG€to€SC€7.€ThisÏmay€be€done€on€a€meeting€per€meeting€basis.ÌÌò ò7.0€Future€Meeting€Scheduleó óÐ ”ä ÐÌ7.1€1995„06„13/15€(ITI)ÌÌ7.2€1995„09„13„15€(ITI)ÌÌò ò8.0€Adjournmentó óÐ #l! ÐÌThe€meeting€was€adjourned€at€11:30€a.m.ÌÐ  à%0!$ ÐÔ‡ XÝÞXXX¬5ÔAttachment€1Ð ° ÐÌAttendees:ÌÌBruce€Bargmeyerà  àà h àEPAÐ P ÐDan€Gillmanà ¸ àà  àà h àBureau€of€CensusÐ Ô$ ÐPaul€Hawesà ¸ àà  àà h àBellcoreÐ ¨ ø ÐTammy€Kirkendallà  àà h àNISTÐ | Ì ÐJoe€Leahyà ` àà ¸ àà  àà h àSAICÐ P   ÐWilliam€Kenworthey,€Jr.à h àSelfñHñÐ $ t  ÐBill€LaPlantà ¸ àà  àà h àOMC€Liaison€to€X3L8ñHñÐ ø H  ÐJudith€Newtonà ¸ àà  àà h àNISTÐ Ì   ÐPhong€Ngoà ` àà ¸ àà  àà h àSAICÐ  ð  ÐFrank€Olkenà ¸ àà  àà h àLBLÐ tÄ  ÐRoger€Payneà ¸ àà  àà h àDepartment€of€InteriorÐ H˜  ÐBruce€Rosenà ¸ àà  àà h àNISTÐ l  ÐÔ#†X¬5XX XÝÞÒ #Ô